🎝you’re gonna carry that weight🎜

Unrelated Preamble

Well, it’s been five calendar years since the last post, hope this one is worth it. Amusingly the first post was right before a major life event and I did some cool stuff after that that I never got around to writing up. Anyway, this post is about things more recent than that, but still over a year old. Maybe I’ll write about some of the other stuff later.

Background

I’m going to assume an audience that has seen a guitar at some point in their life before. There’s a big part that sometimes has a hole on the front, there’s a narrow part, some strings, someone presses strings against the narrow bit with one hand and uses their other hand to hit the strings over the big part to make pleasing noises. If this doesn’t ring any bells for you, please look this up before continuing, or maybe just stop since you might not find the rest interesting.

Anyway now that we’ve got the guitar bit out the way, let’s dive more into the bass guitar bit. Their narrow bit tends to be slightly longer, and they tend to have fewer, thicker strings than a regular guitar. Bass guitar players are typically called bassists. Some of them get upset if you call their instrument a “guitar” and will insist on calling it a “bass”. “Bass” is pronounced like “base” rather than the fish. Congrats, you now know more than like two thirds of the general population on this topic and should be able to approach band members without offending them too much out of ignorance. Or you can feign ignorance of these key points to start fights if you prefer, it’s up to you really.

Motivation

I’m something of a musician

For various reasons I play a bass guitar on the order of about 50 times a year. Over the past decade, this has fluctuated considerably, usually trading sessions with other instruments, such as guitars, keyboards, and drumkits. On occasion I have carted multiple instruments to sessions as required, and with pedalboards and stands I have had some very bulky and somewhat heavy setups to lug around.

These days I’m somewhat privileged in how much is reliably available on-site, and my smallest amount of gear is my instrument and a laptop bag carrying laptop for music reading, instrument lead, headphones, a couple of power bricks for the provided tuner pedal and headphone amp. If I could be satisfied with the two power bricks provided (current tuner pedal brick adds a bit of ambient noise to the signal, current headphone amp brick cannot provide enough power and starts to clip with my low impedance headphones), it would just be instrument, instrument lead, headphones, laptop, which is practically nothing compared to the days when I was lugging a bass amp with a 15” speaker cone among other things. The only times I’ve carted less is when I turn up with literally nothing and play a provided piano or drumkit with foldback wedges or whatever.

So this is a fairly regular gig, and I have a fairly efficient setup, and this is the case circa 2022. I get bored. It’s not a particularly heavy bass, it has a good history with me, it has a comfortable softcase and shoulder strap. It has a few amusing electrical modifications that I’d finished up possibly as early as 2013. I’ve played it in various tunings, often dropping it, prompting approval from one sound guy and disdain from another. At one point I had standard gauge strings tuned down to CG- ah I forget the rest, might have been CGCG - not that it mattered when I played almost all of the set on the lower two strings.

LOWER

Heavy detuning is not without drawbacks - after all, if it were strictly better, that would be the standard tuning. A lot of the brilliance disappears leaving the sound feeling dull and muddy, thumpy. The strings flop about more and require more clearance from frets and pickups to avoid hitting them and making unpleasant noises. Intonation becomes much more sensitive, and small differences in applied finger strength can easily pull notes sharp. All the same, it worked for the set, the people I cared about really liked it, but I dialed it back to DADG after that.

The motivation for dropping down to C was something not that unusual - you get asked to play a song in a certain key that’s a bit lower than usual to please the singers, but it means that you’d have to go up the octave at some parts, or play the whole thing up an octave. My lowest string was already at C# at the time, so I figured why not just drop it that extra semitone. The venue’s subwoofers can handle it, it’s not the greatest sounding thing in the world, but I liked it more than the alternatives.

Now, it’s not like I’d never thought about 5-string basses before this, I’d had them in the back of my mind for over a decade. I had an 8-string electric guitar, I knew the joys of extended range string instruments. I also knew of people who had used 5-string string sets on 4-string basses in BEAD tuning, some firsthand even, but the results weren’t to their liking. I figured now was as good a time as any to seriously look into this, I wanted those low low notes without the compromises.

Yet more tradeoffs

So when it comes to guitars with unusually high numbers of strings, the first thing you might notice is that the neck gets a bit wider to accomodate them. This seems innocent at first, but then you put your hand around it and realize that there’s a bit more stretching involved to play on them. One thing that is less obvious until you pick one up is that they are surprisingly heavy - now I’m sure that there could be models out there that compensate for this, but the 8-string guitars and 5-string basses I have laid hands on are considerably heavier than the 6-string and 4-strings I encounter. Checking spec sheets from my preferred guitar supplier1 convinced me that it was time to get a bit creative on this weight angle, and to be honest, I was unemployed and running down my savings at this point, so I was quite price-sensitive.

Let’s make our own

Round 1

All this time I’ve also picked up some other thoughts, like how useless the traditional body ornaments are for my usual standing playing style, so I envision a narrow stick bass that doesn’t protude further than necessary - something like a narrower Flying-V look, which I would later discover had been done by Steinberger, albeit out of my budget for this. I find a cheap 5-string bass neck, strings, order some tuners and a 5-string J-bass pickup pair off aliexpress. Eventually the stuff arrives. It’s all very exciting, and I chop the headstock short, drill some holes and thread the strings through it. I’m thrilled at how it looks, and then I realize I have no plan for the body part, that I need to sort out a bridge and put tuners behind it. I mull over it for a couple of weeks then shelve it entirely.

Round 2

Months later, I’m sufficiently bothered by seeing the abandoned 5-string neck sitting about my room and I’m ready to do something about it. My younger self would be wrakced by guilt over this and refuse to proceed without making use of this sunken cost failure - but not this self! I’m now a much more ruthless person and able to discard2 things I butcher or otherwise fail to make perfect use of, in order to better proceed and finish some projects! In fact, I’m so ruthless, that I’m even willing to just up and buy a brand new bass (so long as it’s cheap) to chop up to my liking, instead of starting from parts! At this point, I’m also more enamored with the stick bass idea than the 5-string part, after all, if I really care, I can revisit that, in time.

A lovely blue chinese 4-string P-bass clone arrives, I take some photos of it then immediately disassemble it and take it out to meet my trusty circular saw. The headstock goes much like the previous one, and the body gets turned into a narrow plank-shape. I give it a quick edge rounding pass with my router, it’s not pretty nor clean but it takes all the sharp edges off for safer handling.

At this point, I pull out some scrap wood with the intention of mounting the tuners to it and attaching it to the end of the body. None of my drill bits are suitably sized to fit the tuner shafts. Things are looking grim, and at this point I wonder if this is a good quitting point.

If only I had one of those cheap CNC routers that I’d been eyeing for after I engage in economic migration and find a nice place of my own, one of those would have been able to create any sized hole I wanted. Then it hits me - I have a 3D printer.

Plastic? Really?

At this point I had no illusions of 3D printed plastic being suitably strong to replace wood in a load-bearing part. Standard tuning 4-string bass had to have a lot of tension, which would be putting a fairly strong load on this hypothetical tailpiece. Additionally, despite my printer3 being specifically marketed as an ABS printer, I never had a good success rate with that, so I was thinking of trying some lesser filament types which had a reputation for being easier to print at the expense of strength and temperature resistance. With all these weaknesses in mind, I had the following goals:

  1. Aim for a full detune by default
  2. Try to make the tailpiece bear load in the most advantageous way
  3. Assume it will break anyway and maybe make a router guard template for the holes instead next time

Modeling

Classical 3d modeling has never been one of my strong points. OpenSCAD is a lovely little program that allows me to define geometry as if I were writing code. All of my previous 3d printed designs were done this way, and I enjoyed structuring them in this way with the ability to later tweak numeric variables to fit tolerances after test prints. I have an online friend who would have instead just done this in Blender, likely blasphemy to hardcore CAD types, but I’m not very opinionated on this other than using what I’m already comfortable with.

Most of my time was spent taking physical measurements and reasoning about them, the actual geometry defining part was very straight-forward.

Printing

I had some unopened green PolyMaker® PolyMax™ PLA left over from the various things I initially bought with my printer back in 2017. I took a few iterations to sort out tolerances, and I also designed a pickup holder that protrudes from the narrow body and has a convenient audio jack position. Surprisingly, this PLA proved quite rigid and printed like a charm.

Let’s make another one

Half the weight of my previous bass turned out to be really nice. Then I see this video. I instantly fall in love. It’s so small. It uses regular guitar tuners instead of heavier bass tuners. The bridge is ridiculous. The pickup is wrong. It plays. It plays. It plays.

My target has strayed from 5 string to 2 strings. From adding one to subtracting two. From 1.25Ă— to 0.5Ă—.

I have newfound trust in an easy-to-print filament material. I have perverse ideas that I can make a reality.

Present Day Present Time

With an enjoyable 2-string bass and an enjoyable 4-string bass in hand, I now seek a 3-string compromise. This one will taper.

  1. I am a long-time customer of Artist Guitars. ↩

  2. To storage, not the tip. Don’t throw that out, I might need part of it one day! ↩

  3. Tiertime UP! Box+ DO NOT BUY ANYTHING FROM TIERTIME. I DO NOT HAVE A SINGLE POSITIVE THING TO SAY ABOUT THEM OR THEIR PRODUCTS. Unless you want to take my old one off my hands for new Bambu money, in which case, caveat emptor and thank you very much! ↩